Search
Close this search box.

ASTM A105 vs A350 LF2: Which Forging Grade to Specify

Specifying the wrong carbon steel forging grade for a piping system is a costly mistake. The two most commonly compared ASTM forging materials — ASTM A105 and ASTM A350 LF2 — look nearly identical on a purchase order, yet they are qualified for very different service conditions. A105 is the default choice for ambient-temperature pipe fittings and flanges, while A350 LF2 is the go-to grade when sub-zero temperatures demand proven impact toughness. This guide explains exactly where each grade belongs, how their chemistry and mechanical properties differ, and how to specify them correctly so you do not overpay — or worse, install a fitting that is unsafe for the service.

The practical rule is simple: for systems operating above -29 degC (-20 degF), A105 is normally sufficient and more economical. Below that threshold, or where the code requires documented low-temperature impact testing, you need A350 LF2. Everything else — chemistry, strength, machining behaviour — is broadly similar. We unpack the details below so you can make a confident, code-compliant decision.

What Is ASTM A105?

ASTM A105 / A105M is the standard specification for carbon steel forgings for piping applications, covering fittings, flanges, and valves for ambient and higher-temperature service. It is the workhorse grade of the piping industry and appears in virtually every refinery, power plant, and water-treatment project. A105 is supplied in the normalized, annealed, or quenched-and-tempered condition depending on the order, and it is available in a wide range of pressure classes from Class 150 through Class 2500 under ASME B16.5 and B16.11.

Because A105 is so widely produced, it is stocked in large quantities by mills and distributors around the world. That availability translates into short lead times and competitive pricing. The trade-off is that standard A105 carries no mandatory Charpy impact test requirement, so it should not be assumed suitable for cold climates or cryogenic service without supplementary testing.

ASTM A105 vs A350 LF2 application

What Is ASTM A350 LF2?

ASTM A350 LF2 is a low-alloy, carbon-steel forging grade specifically developed for low-temperature piping components. The “LF” designation stands for low-temperature ferritic steel, and the “2” identifies the specific chemistry and toughness class. Unlike A105, A350 LF2 mandates Charpy V-notch impact testing — typically at -46 degC (-50 degF) with a minimum absorbed energy of 20 J (15 ft-lb) — and it imposes tighter controls on chemistry and heat treatment to guarantee toughness at cold temperatures.

LF2 is the standard material for flanges, fittings, and valves in LNG terminals, arctic pipelines, refrigerated storage, and any process where brittle fracture is a concern. It is normalized or quenched-and-tempered, and the spec allows several classes (Class 1 and Class 2) keyed to different heat-treatment and strength levels. Buyers should always state the class and the required impact test temperature on the purchase order.

A105 vs A350 LF2: Key Differences at a Glance

Chemical Composition Comparison

The two grades are close in composition, which is why they are sometimes — incorrectly — treated as interchangeable. The meaningful difference is not the nominal chemistry but the tighter control and the mandatory toughness qualification that LF2 requires. The table shows typical maximum values in weight percent.

Element (max %)ASTM A105ASTM A350 LF2
Carbon (C)0.350.30
Manganese (Mn)1.05 (1.35 with C lower)0.60-1.35
Phosphorus (P)0.0350.025
Sulfur (S)0.0400.025
Silicon (Si)0.10-0.350.15-0.30
Copper (Cu)0.400.40
Nickel (Ni)0.400.50
Chromium (Cr)0.300.30
Molybdenum (Mo)0.120.12

Notice that LF2 holds phosphorus and sulfur to 0.025 percent, compared with 0.035 and 0.040 for A105. Lower phosphorus and sulfur reduce the risk of brittle fracture and improve notch toughness — a small chemistry change that matters a great deal when the component sees impact loading in the cold.

ASTM A105 vs A350 LF2 stock

Mechanical Properties Comparison

At room temperature the two grades have broadly similar strength. The distinction emerges in impact performance, not in yield or tensile strength. Both grades comfortably meet the pressure-rating requirements of ASME flanges at ambient temperature.

PropertyASTM A105ASTM A350 LF2 Class 1
Tensile strength (min)485 MPa (70 ksi)485 MPa (70 ksi)
Yield strength (min)250 MPa (36 ksi)250 MPa (36 ksi)
Elongation in 50 mm (min)22%22%
Reduction of area (min)30%30%
Hardness (max)HB 187 (typical)HB 207
Charpy impactNot required by default20 J at -46 degC (min avg)

Low-Temperature Toughness: The Deciding Factor

Brittle fracture is a sudden, catastrophic failure mode in which a steel component cracks without significant plastic deformation. Carbon steels undergo a ductile-to-brittle transition as temperature falls; below a certain point, the energy required to propagate a crack drops sharply. A105, with its coarser chemistry control and no impact-test requirement, sits above that transition only at ambient and warm temperatures. A350 LF2 is produced and tested specifically to remain ductile at low temperature.

This is why codes such as ASME B31.3 and B31.8 restrict A105 fittings in low-temperature service and call for LF2 or an equivalent impact-tested grade. If a project specification says “low-temperature carbon steel,” assume LF2 is required unless the engineer explicitly permits an alternative. Substituting A105 to save money in this service is a false economy: the cost of a single fitting is trivial compared with the consequences of a brittle failure.

Heat Treatment Requirements

A350 LF2 is normally supplied normalized, or normalized and tempered, and the specification defines classes that correspond to different heat-treatment routes and strength levels. Class 2, for example, is quenched and tempered to achieve higher strength. The heat treatment is not optional — it is what develops the fine grain structure that delivers low-temperature toughness. Buyers should request the heat-treatment condition on the certificate.

A105 forgings may be supplied annealed, normalized, or quenched and tempered. For standard ambient flanges and fittings, the as-forged or normalized condition is common. When A105 is needed for slightly colder duty, purchasers sometimes add a supplementary impact-test requirement (an “S” supplementary requirement) — but this still does not equal a true LF2 qualification, and it should only be done with engineering approval.

Weldability and Fabrication

Both grades are readily weldable using common carbon-steel consumables (for example E7018 / ER70S-6). Because LF2 is often used in low-temperature service, welding procedure specifications should account for preheat and interpass temperature control, and filler metal should be selected to match the toughness requirement — an E7018 filler with low-temperature impact qualification is typical. Post-weld heat treatment is generally not required for either grade in thin sections but may be specified for thick forgings or critical service.

Machinability is similar, with A105 slightly softer in some conditions. Both grades machine well with carbide tooling at conventional speeds. The main fabrication caution for LF2 is to avoid practices that coarsen the grain structure — excessive heat input or improper heat treatment can degrade the toughness that the buyer paid for.

Typical Applications of A105

Typical Applications of A350 LF2

Cost and Availability

A105 is the clear winner on price and availability. It is produced in enormous volumes, stocked in every pressure class and size, and can usually ship from warehouse stock. A350 LF2 carries a price premium — typically 15 to 40 percent above A105 depending on size and class — because of tighter chemistry, mandatory heat treatment, and impact testing, and it may require a mill production slot. For large projects, plan LF2 procurement early in the schedule.

How to Choose: 5 Decision Factors

Procurement Checklist for Both Grades

Pressure Classes and Dimension Standards

Both A105 and A350 LF2 forgings are manufactured to the same family of dimension standards, so choosing the grade does not change the geometry of the fitting. Flanges follow ASME B16.5 for sizes NPS 1/2 through 24 and ASME B16.47 for larger diameters; socket-weld and threaded fittings follow ASME B16.11; and butt-welding fittings follow ASME B16.9. Pressure classes range from Class 150 to Class 2500, and the material grade must be rated for the design pressure and temperature of the service.

A subtle point catches many buyers: the pressure-temperature rating of an A105 flange is published in ASME B16.5, but that rating assumes the material meets the A105 chemistry and strength requirements. An impact-tested LF2 flange of the same class will carry the same pressure rating at ambient temperature, but it also carries the additional low-temperature qualification. You are paying for toughness, not for extra pressure capacity.

When ordering, specify the dimension standard and pressure class alongside the material grade. “A350 LF2 Class 150 slip-on flange, ASME B16.5, RF face, B16.5 bolts” is unambiguous; “LF2 flange” is not. Clear documentation of this kind is the first line of defence against receiving a fitting that does not fit the line.

Marking and Traceability Requirements

Traceability is what connects a physical fitting to its test certificate. Reputable forgings are marked with the manufacturer name or logo, the material grade (A105 or A350 LF2), the heat number, the pressure class, and the size. The heat number is the key: it links the fitting to a specific melt of steel and therefore to a specific mill test certificate. Without it, the certificate is meaningless.

Common Specification Mistakes (and How to Avoid Them)

One frequent error is ordering A105 for a project whose design minimum temperature is just below the carbon-steel transition range, on the assumption that “it rarely gets that cold.” Codes do not work on assumptions. If the design minimum temperature crosses the threshold, the compliant material is LF2 or an approved alternative, regardless of local experience.

A second mistake is accepting a certificate that lists chemistry but no impact data for LF2. The impact test is the entire reason for specifying LF2; a certificate without it does not prove low-temperature suitability. A third is failing to state the LF2 class — Class 1 and Class 2 differ in heat treatment and strength — leaving the supplier to choose.

Finally, buyers sometimes request A105 with a supplementary impact test as a cheaper substitute for LF2. This can be acceptable in limited cases with engineering approval, but it is not automatically equivalent to a true LF2 qualification and should never be done silently.

Practical Selection Examples

Consider a refinery piping line operating at 200 degC in a temperate climate. A105 is the correct, economical choice: the temperature is well above the brittle range, no impact test is required, and the grade is stocked in every class. Paying for LF2 here would add cost without adding value.

Now consider a gas processing plant in northern Canada with a design minimum temperature of -45 degC. A105 is not acceptable. A350 LF2 with Charpy testing at -46 degC is the standard selection, and the purchase order must state the class and test temperature. The small premium is trivial compared with the safety margin it buys.

Between these extremes lie borderline cases — a pipeline that sees occasional cold snaps, or equipment that may be relocated. In such cases the prudent approach is to specify LF2 if there is any doubt, or to ask the engineer of record to confirm the minimum design metal temperature formally.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use A105 fittings at sub-zero temperatures?

Generally no. Standard A105 has no mandatory impact test and should not be used below the code-defined minimum (commonly -29 degC) unless an approved supplementary test is specified and accepted by the engineer.

Is A350 LF2 stronger than A105?

At room temperature their minimum tensile and yield strengths are essentially the same. LF2 is selected for toughness at low temperature, not for higher ambient strength.

What temperature is LF2 rated for?

A350 LF2 is commonly Charpy-tested at -46 degC (-50 degF) with a minimum absorbed energy of 20 J, making it suitable for design minimum temperatures around that level. Confirm the exact test temperature on the certificate.

Are A105 and LF2 dimensions interchangeable?

Yes. Both are manufactured to the same ASME dimension standards and pressure classes, so an LF2 fitting fits where an A105 fitting fits. The difference is material qualification, not geometry.

Which grade should I order for a hot oil line?

A105. For ambient and elevated-temperature service, A105 is fully compliant and more economical. Reserve LF2 for low-temperature duty.

Frequently Overlooked Details in A105 vs LF2 Orders

Beyond grade and temperature, several details commonly cause rework on piping projects. One is the flange face type: raised face, flat face, and ring-type joint faces are not interchangeable, and the gasket and mating flange must match. Another is the bolting specification — the studs, nuts, and gaskets that accompany a flange should be rated for the same service conditions as the flange itself. An LF2 flange bolted with low-grade studs in cold service defeats the purpose of the tougher material.

Coating and corrosion protection also deserve attention. Both A105 and LF2 forgings are supplied bare, with a light oil, or with a protective coating depending on the order. In buried or offshore service, the coating system must be compatible with the service temperature and with any cathodic protection. Buyers should state the coating requirement explicitly rather than assuming the forging arrives protected.

Lead time is a practical consideration that is easy to underestimate. A105 in common sizes and classes is widely stocked and can often ship immediately. A350 LF2, particularly in large diameters or high pressure classes, may require a mill production slot plus impact testing, extending delivery by several weeks. For a project with a tight shutdown window, plan LF2 procurement early and confirm the mill schedule before committing to the installation date.

Finally, documentation quality varies between suppliers. A clear purchase order that names the grade, class, dimension standard, pressure class, face type, impact test temperature, and certificate type removes almost all ambiguity. When each of these elements is documented, the risk of receiving a non-compliant or unsuitable fitting falls sharply, and incoming inspection becomes a confirmation rather than a discovery exercise.

Request a Quote

Need a quotation for ASTM A105 or ASTM A350 LF2 flanges and fittings? Huaxia-Steel supplies both grades with full traceability and mill certificates. Tell us your size, pressure class, and service temperature and we will recommend the compliant, cost-effective grade.

Contact our sales team at [email protected] with your specification, quantity, and destination port. We reply with a mill-direct quotation, lead time, and full documentation within one business day.

Request A Free Quote

 Or contact us to see our certificates

We’d like to work with you

If you require further information about our metal sheet products or architectural projects, please don’t hesitate to leave your contact details and message here.

Our team of experts will respond within 24 hours to continue the discussion and provide you with any additional information you requires.